When a plumbing job damages a customer’s home, the property damage coverage in your general liability policy is usually what pays for the walls, floors, ceilings, cabinets and belongings your work damaged, whether the damage happens while you are on site or after you have left. What it generally does not pay for is redoing your own work, and a few kinds of damage, such as sewage releases and damage to your own tools, fall under other policies or other rules.
So the answer to “what pays?” is usually several answers, one for each piece of the loss. This post sorts them out.
What does property damage coverage on a plumber’s policy pay for?
It pays for physical damage to property that belongs to someone else when your work causes it, along with the loss of use of that property. In a home, that typically means water-damaged drywall, insulation, flooring, trim and cabinets, damaged furniture and belongings, and in some cases the cost of the family staying elsewhere while repairs are made, depending on how the policy and the claim are handled.
It also pays to defend you if the customer or their insurer claims you caused the damage, even when the claim is disputed. That defense is often as valuable as the payment itself.
The coverage applies up to the limits on your declarations page, and after any deductible your policy carries. The NAIC’s small business insurance page gives a plain overview of how liability coverage works for a business.
Does it matter whether the damage happens during the job or after?
It matters for how the policy is read, not usually for whether you are covered. Damage that happens while you are working falls under ongoing operations. Damage that happens after the job is done, such as a fitting that fails weeks later, falls under products-completed operations, which carries its own aggregate limit on many policies.
Both are typically part of the same general liability policy. The difference shows up in which limit is used, and in whether a policy that was in force when the damage happened is the one that responds. The post on whether general liability covers water damage after the job explains the completed-operations side in detail.
Which parts of the damage are not paid?
Several exclusions shape every property damage claim, and knowing them keeps you from being surprised.
- Your own work. General liability is not a warranty. The cost of tearing out and replacing a fitting, a water heater installation or a run of pipe you installed generally stays with you. The post on the “your work” exclusion explains where that line falls.
- The part you were working on. Many forms exclude damage to the particular part of real property you were working on when the damage arises from that work. The fixture you cracked during installation may not be covered, while the water damage it causes elsewhere usually is.
- Property in your care. Property you are holding or controlling for the customer can fall outside coverage, depending on the wording.
- Pollutants. Sewage and other contaminants are limited under standard forms. Drain and sewer work needs its own review, covered below.
- Expected or intended damage. Damage you meant to cause, such as cutting into a wall to reach a pipe, is part of the job, not an accident.
The post on general liability exclusions plumbing contractors should know goes through the rest of the list.
Who pays for the customer’s belongings and other trades’ work?
Your general liability usually does, when your work caused the damage. That includes furniture, rugs, electronics and stored belongings damaged by water, as well as finishes installed by other trades, such as tile, flooring, cabinets and paint.
On remodels and new construction this matters more than people expect. If your leak damages finished work another contractor completed, the cost to repair their work can be part of your claim. On larger projects, builders risk coverage arranged by the owner or general contractor may respond first, and then the question becomes whether that insurer pursues you.
Damage to a neighbor’s property is treated the same way. A failed supply line in an upper unit that damages the units below can bring claims from several owners at once, all against the same limits.
Does a residential job change how the claim works?
The coverage is the same, but the claim tends to feel different. In a home, the person whose property was damaged is usually the person who hired you, they are often living in the space while repairs happen, and their kitchen or bathroom may be out of use for a while. Emotions run higher than on a commercial job, and how your company behaves in the first days affects whether the customer stays with you.
Residential service companies also see more frequent, smaller claims: a slow leak under a vanity, a water heater connection that drips into a finished basement, a drain line disturbed during a fixture swap. Each one is a property damage claim, and each one should be reported. The residential plumbing services page describes the kinds of work we insure for service plumbers.
What residential claims rarely involve is your own equipment. If a drain machine falls down the stairs or a camera is crushed on the job, that is a loss to your property, not the customer’s, and it belongs to contractors equipment coverage, not general liability.
Where does the property owner’s own insurer fit in?
Often it pays first. The customer calls their own insurer, which pays for repairs under the customer’s policy and then pursues the contractor it believes caused the loss. That process is called subrogation, and it is a routine part of water damage claims.
When that demand arrives, it usually comes as a letter from the other insurer or its attorney. Do not answer it yourself, and do not agree to pay. Send it to your agent, who passes it to your carrier. If the damage is covered, your carrier handles the response and any payment on your behalf.
What should you do in the first hours after a job causes damage?
What you do quickly shapes how the claim goes.
Stop the source and limit further damage. Shut off the water, contain what you can, and call a water mitigation company if the damage is significant. Most policies expect you to take reasonable steps to protect property from further harm.
Document everything. Take photos and video of the damage, the failed part and the area around it before anything is removed. Keep the failed part if you can, since it may matter later to a carrier or to a supplier.
Report it to your agent the same day, even if the damage looks minor. Policies require prompt notice, and water damage tends to grow once walls and floors are opened.
Be helpful to the customer without admitting fault or promising payment. Tell them you have reported it and that someone will be in touch.
Real-World Scenario: A service technician replaces a supply line under a second-floor bathroom sink. Later that evening the connection lets go and water runs through the floor into the kitchen below. The owner of the plumbing company sends a crew back, shuts off the water and photographs the damage before the drywall is opened. The company reports the incident that night. General liability pays for the ceiling, cabinets and flooring below, while the company covers the cost of its own return trip and the new supply line.
Should you ever pay for small damage yourself?
Some owners prefer to repair small damage directly to protect their claims record or avoid a deductible. That can be reasonable, but only after you have reported the incident to your agent. A claim that seems small on day one can grow after hidden moisture is found, and if you did not give timely notice, the carrier may dispute coverage when the bigger bill arrives.
If you decide together to handle a minor repair yourself, get the customer’s sign-off in writing that the repair resolves the matter. Keep the records with your job file.
Reducing how often damage happens is still the best protection. The post on how to reduce claims in a plumbing business covers the habits that make the biggest difference.
How do you check your policy before the next job?
Look at your general liability declarations page and note the per-occurrence limit, the products-completed operations aggregate and any deductible. Then ask your agent to show you the exclusions discussed above and any endorsements that change them, especially the pollution wording if you do drain or sewer work. If you do, pollution liability may belong in your program.
If you would like someone to read your current policy against the work you do, ask us for a review or a quote. You can also find out who we are and how we work with plumbing contractors.