A plumbing business gets workers compensation from one of two sources, a state fund or a private carrier, and your state decides which ones are open to you. Pay-as-you-go is not a third source: it is a way of paying for a private (or sometimes state fund) policy in step with each payroll, instead of through a deposit and a year-end audit.
This is general education, not legal advice. Workers comp rules are set state by state and change over time, so confirm how your state works with its workers compensation agency before you hire or sign a contract.
Who decides which workers comp options your plumbing company has?
Your state does, before any carrier or agent gets a say. States fall into a few groups for workers compensation, and each group gives a plumbing employer a different set of choices.
In the four monopolistic states, North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming, comp comes only from the state fund. No private carrier can write it, so the decision is about how you manage the state policy, not where you buy it. A plumbing company with crews in Ohio handles comp directly with the state system and buys its other lines privately.
Most states are private-market states. Private carriers write comp through agents, and some of these states also run a state fund that competes alongside them. Texas stands apart because comp is generally elective for most private employers there; the Texas location page covers what that means for a plumbing company.
If your crews cross state lines, each state where employees work has to be addressed. The Department of Labor keeps a directory of state workers’ compensation officials where you can find the agency for each one.
What does a state fund offer a plumbing employer?
A state fund is a workers comp insurer run by or for the state. In a monopolistic state it is the only option. In a state where it competes with private carriers, it is one more market to compare.
For plumbing contractors, a competitive state fund can be useful in a few situations. A new business with no claims history may find private carriers hesitant, and the state fund may write it. A company whose crew does trench or confined-space work may find fewer private carriers interested in that class. The state fund can also serve as a baseline against which private offers are measured.
What it may not offer is flexibility. State funds tend to work on standard forms and fixed procedures, and their service is built for volume. Ask the fund how it handles certificates, mid-term changes and claim reporting, because those are the parts of comp a plumbing company touches most often.
The only source in monopolistic states. A competing option in some others.
Standard forms and fixed procedures.
Placed through an agent in private-market states.
Appetite varies by class code and claims history.
A billing method, not a source. Premium follows each payroll run.
The policy is still audited after the term.
When does a private carrier make more sense?
In a private-market state, most established plumbing companies end up with a private carrier. The reasons are practical. Private carriers compete for accounts they like, so a company with steady payroll, clear job duties and a clean claims record can often find better terms than the default.
Private carriers also differ from each other. One may prefer residential service work and avoid underground crews. Another may welcome commercial and new-construction plumbers but want detailed safety records. An independent agency that works with several carriers can match the work to the market instead of forcing the account into the first one that answers. The post on where to get workers comp for plumbing employees walks through that buying process step by step.
A private policy can also sit beside your general liability and auto with the same agency, which makes certificates and renewals easier. Whether that arrangement helps you is covered in the post on bundled liability and workers comp.
What does pay-as-you-go actually change?
It changes the timing of the money, not the coverage. A traditional comp policy starts with an estimated payroll. You pay a deposit and installments based on that estimate, and after the term ends, an auditor compares the estimate to your actual payroll. If you grew, you owe more. If you shrank, you get some back.
Pay-as-you-go replaces the estimate with real figures as you go. Each time you run payroll, usually through a payroll service connected to the carrier, the wages for that period are reported and the premium for that period is charged. The deposit is often smaller, and the audit at the end usually finds less to adjust.
That suits a plumbing company whose payroll moves around: a seasonal backlog, a large new-construction job that adds a crew for a few months, or a growing service company that hires through the year. It suits less well a company that wants to keep comp separate from its payroll provider, or one whose payroll provider’s program uses a carrier that does not fit the work.
The coverage itself is still a workers comp policy with the same benefits your state sets. Read it as you would any other.
Real-World Scenario: A plumbing company that mostly does service work takes on a large commercial job and adds a crew for the season. On its traditional comp policy, the payroll estimate was set before the job existed, and the owner faces a sizeable bill at audit after the crew is gone. At the next renewal the agency places comp with a carrier that offers pay-as-you-go through the company’s payroll service. The following season the added crew’s wages are reported as they are paid, and the audit has little left to settle.
What if no carrier wants your plumbing crew?
Many states have a residual market, often called an assigned risk plan, for employers that cannot buy comp in the voluntary market. It exists so that an employer who needs coverage can get it. The terms are often less favorable, and the service can be slower, but it keeps a crew legally covered while the company builds a record.
New plumbing businesses sometimes start there, and so do companies after a serious claim. Treat it as a stage, not a home. The levers that move a company back into the voluntary market are the same ones that move comp pricing generally: accurate classification, safety practices, prompt claim reporting and return-to-work. The post on what drives plumbing workers comp costs covers each one.
How do class codes and job hazards affect every option?
Whatever the source, comp is priced and underwritten by how your employees are classified. Field plumbers, office staff and drivers are typically sorted differently, and a plumber who spends time in trenches or confined spaces raises questions a service technician does not. The post on trenches, confined spaces and workers comp explains why those exposures carry so much weight.
Describe the work accurately on every application, whether it goes to a state fund, a private carrier or a payroll provider’s program. A crew classified for lighter work than it does creates trouble at audit and can complicate a claim.
Should owners and subcontractors be on the policy?
Owners are a separate question. Many states let certain owners and officers include or exclude themselves from coverage, and the rules differ by entity type and by state. Ask your agent what your state allows and what each choice means if you are hurt on a job.
Subcontractors matter at audit. If you pay a subcontractor who cannot show their own comp certificate, the carrier may treat that payment as your payroll. Collect certificates before work starts, every time.
How do you choose between the options?
Start with your state, because it may make the choice for you. Then ask an agent to show you what each available source offers for your actual payroll and work, and ask whether a pay-as-you-go arrangement is available with the carriers that fit. Compare the written terms, the class codes used and the service, not only the price.
Then look at how each option fits the stage your company is in. A new plumbing business hiring its first employee often cares most about getting covered quickly and keeping the deposit small, which can point toward a state fund or a pay-as-you-go program; the post on low-cost insurance for a new plumbing business covers that early sequence. An established company with a steady crew and a clean record usually has more private carriers to choose from and more reason to shop them. A company that has just had a serious injury may need to accept the residual market for a term and plan its way back.
Revisit the choice at each renewal. Payroll, crew size, the mix of service and project work, and the states you work in all change, and the option that fit last year may not fit now.
If you are not sure which option fits your crews, we can lay out the choices for each state you work in. Request a quote with your payroll by job type, or read how our agency works with plumbing contractors on comp. The workers compensation coverage page has the basics of what the policy pays.